You are here: Home - Household Bills - News -

Which? accuses letting agents of breaking consumer law

Written by:
Letting agents across England may be breaching consumer law by demanding deposits before allowing renters to see their contracts, a Which? investigation has found.

Which? visited 20 letting agents across England, posing as prospective tenants seeking to rent a property.

Its mystery shoppers asked to see a copy of the terms and conditions they would be signing up to, but one in four agents failed to provide a contract.

In some cases the letting agent requested a reference check to be paid for and completed before they saw the terms of the contract.

Which? emphasised that letting agents have a duty by law to provide prospective tenants with the key information they need to make an informed decision about the letting.

The consumer watchdog said it believes demanding a financial commitment before tenants can view the terms and conditions could fall foul of consumer law by trapping tenants in contracts they have not had an opportunity to review.


Five letting agents, including a branch of Connells, required a commitment or a holding deposit before the tenants could view a sample letting agreement.

A spokesperson from Connells told Mortgage Solutions this was not company policy and a draft tenancy agreement should be freely available on request.

“We certainly do not insist on a deposit being paid as a condition of providing the draft,” she said.

“Staff have clear directives on best practice and we would be keen to know the branch in question and circumstances surrounding the request in order to refresh our colleagues understanding of this and their obligations to the customer.”

Further, three of the letting agents that required a commitment or deposit before tenants could see a contract are members of the Association of Residential Letting Agents (ARLA).

However, David Cox, chief executive of Arla Propertymark, disputed the research’s findings.

He said there was no legal requirement in England or Wales to have a tenancy agreement, and as legal statute overrides contract, any unreasonable terms in a contract would be unenforceable in a court of law.

He added: “As such, we would question the suggestion that agents are breaching consumer protection law. We have long been advocating for a legal requirement to have a written tenancy agreement, as they have in Scotland, to avoid many of the misunderstandings cited in this research.

“Which? implies that even the Ministry of Housing Communities and Local Government’s (MHCLG) template tenancy agreement is in breach of their best practice; this demonstrates just how complex the issue around terms and conditions can be.”

Government code of practice

Which? also found evidence of unclear language that could confuse tenants in at least eight contracts, including vague descriptions that tenants may be required to pay a “reasonable” amount or “a fair proportion of” additional charges.

The investigation suggested tenants could not always trust letting agents to act in their best interests with some agencies apparently skirting the law.

As a result, Which? said it was is calling on the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to investigate further issues relating to practices and tenancy terms and conditions in the rental sector and to take action where needed.

Natalie Hitchins, head of home products and services, said that it is outrageous that some agents are demanding cash up front before tenants are even shown a contract, committing them to agreements before they know what they are signing up to.

She added: “The results of this Which? investigation show how vital it is for the government to introduce a legally enforceable code of practice to ensure all letting agents act in a professional manner.

“The CMA must also investigate the sector and take action where needed to tackle unfair practices and contract terms.”

Related Posts

There are 0 Comment(s)

If you wish to comment without signing in, click your cursor in the top box and tick the 'Sign in as a guest' box at the bottom.

Your right to a refund if travel is affected by train strikes

There have been a wave of train strikes in the past six months, and for anyone travelling today Friday 3 Febru...

Could you save money with a social broadband tariff?

Two-thirds of low-income households are unaware they could be saving on broadband, according to Uswitch.

How to help others and donate to food banks this winter

This winter is expected to be the most challenging yet for the food bank network as soaring costs push more pe...

What will happen if rates change

How your finances will be impacted by a rise in interest rates.

Regular Savings Calculator

Small regular contributions can build up nicely over time.

Online Savings Calculator

Work out how your online savings can build over time.

DIY investors: 10 common mistakes to avoid

For those without the help and experience of an adviser, here are 10 common DIY investor mistakes to avoid.

Mortgage down-valuations: Tips to avoid pulling out of a house sale

Down-valuations are on the rise. So, what does it mean for home buyers, and what can you do?

Five tips for surviving a bear market mauling

The S&P 500 has slipped into bear market territory and for UK investors, the FTSE 250 is also on the edge. Her...

Money Tips of the Week