Save, make, understand money

Experienced Investor

Is your money in an underperforming dog fund?

Paloma Kubiak
Written By:
Paloma Kubiak

The amount of cash in seriously underperforming funds has rocketed five-fold since the start of 2018. Is your money languishing in one or more of them?

The twice-yearly name and shame list reveals there are seven £1bn+ funds lagging, up from one in the previous period, and a total of 58 make the league – an increase of 123% since the previous edition.

But a starker figure reveals that the level of assets in underperforming funds has rocketed to £33.6bn, more than five times the £6.4bn reported just six months ago. According to Bestinvest, which compiles the ‘Spot the Dog’ report, this is the most amount of money in dog funds on record.

Is your money in a dog fund?

Dog funds are those which fail to beat their relevant benchmark over three consecutive 12-month periods and also by 5% or more over the full three-year period. It covers unit trusts and OEICs from a number of Investment Association equity sectors.

The largest number of dog funds remain in the Global sector, with 19 funds identified.

At the top of the shame list is Invesco Perpetual, which had no dogs in the previous edition, and this time, five make an appearance. These include the firm’s flagship Invesco Perpetual’s High Income and Income funds, respectively weighing in at £9.4bn and £4.5bn. In total, the five firms account for 45% of the total amount of assets in this edition.

Three of these funds are run by UK equity manager Mark Barnett, who inherited the firm’s flagship UK equity funds from star manager, Neil Woodford.

Recently merged Aberdeen Standard Investments also sees five funds make the list, though it draws attention away from Aberdeen’s previous record of 11 funds.

JP Morgan Asset Management secures its place due to a single but sizeable fund – the £3.47bn JPM US Equity Income fund. Bestinvest said this is likely due to its income seeking strategy being out of favour with market trends, such as FAANG stocks. But it added that in tougher market conditions, this fund is likely to prove more defensive than most US funds.

Fund giant Janus Henderson has worked its way up the rankings from 9th to 3rd place in this edition, with two completely new incumbents in the kennel. These are Janus Henderson European Selected Opportunities, and the much smaller Janus Henderson World Select fund.

Fidelity also makes the top five ranking, adding one more fund but over £800m of assets since the start of the year. Fidelity Japan is a repeat offender and the Fidelity American Special Situations fund and Fidelity MoneyBuilder Growth also make the list.

Time to switch?

Jason Hollands, managing director at Bestinvest, said: “There are numerous reasons why a fund might hit a period of relative underperformance and so it’s important to delve deeper before deciding to switch and move your cash elsewhere.

“In some cases, bad decision making is at fault, and the case to move on makes sense but in others a previously sound investment process or an agreed mandate may be out of favour with recent market trends, in which case some patience is required. For example, some of the global and US funds listed in this edition have income generation as part of their objectives and this has led them to be underweight the fashionable “growth” stocks that have performed particularly well in recent years but where dividends are low or non-existent.”