Short selling – a gamble, or prudence?

0
Written by:
29/10/2015
Profiting from downward trending stocks might sound like a contradiction in terms. However, the principle forms the basis of an investment tactic – ‘shorting’.

Shorting, or selling short, is the practice of ‘borrowing’ overvalued shares from a broker and selling them in the hope the price drops.

If the price drops between the time the shares are borrowed and sold, profit is made.

“Short-selling opportunities are most commonly created by bubble markets – sectors that become seriously inflated, and sharply correct when the market turns against them,” explains Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell.

“Similarly, assets which trade regularly, such as stocks, also become overvalued fairly frequently. The key to shorting is identifying which securities may be overvalued, when they might decline, and what price they could reach.”

A controversial approach

Short selling is a highly controversial approach. Keith Loudon, senior partner at stockbroker Redmayne-Bentley, brands it “dangerous and reckless”.

“Short selling is a ploy for the naïve, the gambler and the crook. Leave it alone. Fingers can be burned, perhaps fatally,” he says.

Even those with a less negative view of short selling recognise the practice to be a supremely risky one. As Mould notes, the principal risk of short selling a stock is that it will in fact increase in value while you hold it, resulting in a loss.

Tom Stevenson, investment director at Fidelity Worldwide Investment, believes shorting reverses the risk trade-off of standard investing as a result.

“When you buy a share, the upside is infinite, and the downside limited to 100 per cent. With a short sale, the upside is capped at 100 per cent and losses are theoretically open-ended,” he says.

“Even if you are correct about a share being overvalued, the timing of any correction is hard to predict. In a rising market, short sellers find themselves in a more uncomfortable position than holders of shares in a falling market, who can simply hold on and wait for better times. As John Maynard Keynes said, markets can remain irrational for longer than you can remain solvent.”

As stock markets tend to go up over time, shorting is effectively a bet against the fundamental character of the market. Short selling is also typically a leveraged approach, subsidised with borrowed money.

As with any leveraged investment, investors can be vulnerable to margin calls, and consequently required to stump up more cash to maintain a position if a trade goes the wrong way.

Short selling investors also miss out on the benefits of owning a share as they are obliged to pass on dividends received while their positions are open to the owner of the shares. However, they are liable for any interest accrued on the borrowed margin.

Constructive, not destructive

Despite its controversial standing, shorting is not exclusively the preserve of high-stakes day traders. Many professional investors use the technique for constructive purposes.

“By shorting, investors can benefit from both losers and winners in a specific industry – for instance, an investor can buy up shares in a smartphone provider they expect to take market share, while simultaneously shorting another smartphone company that looks like it’s losing ground,” says Mould. This practice is known as pairs trading.

Stevenson notes some use also shorting as a hedge, to de-risk their portfolios.

“For example, an investor may short the market as a whole if they are nervous about a short-term correction, but do not wish to unwind individual stock positions about which they remain positive,” he says.

“It could be argued that shorting actually makes markets more efficient, by providing two way liquidity – otherwise financial markets might be biased towards an overly optimistic view that leads to overvaluation.”

Professional shorting

Fund managers are increasingly using shorting in their investment strategies. For Stevenson, this development is welcome, as short selling is best left to skilled professionals. As long as investors understand the risks involved and are reassured their fund manager is managing these risks appropriately, investors need not be concerned if their fund adopts the strategy.

Stephen Peters, investment analyst at broker Charles Stanley, notes funds with ‘130/30’ portfolios – funds with 30 per cent leverage to enhance returns from rising markets, plus a 30 per cent short portfolio to profit from overpriced stocks – are prevalent in the US. However this approach has as yet failed to catch on in the UK.

“Some managers are good at shorting stocks, others are not. It takes skill and experience to be able to do so, and it takes skill and experience to be able to identify managers that have that ability,” says Peters.

Given the skill and risk involved, funds using short selling strategies typically charge higher fees. While Peters believes there is no reason to necessarily avoid a fund engaged in shorting, the fees are only worth it if the manager actually adds value by doing so, so keeping a close eye on the fund’s performance is vital.

“Extra care should be taken to ensure the manager is short selling in a controlled way, that you as an investor know and understand what the manager is doing, that you understand the different risks being taken and that you are prepared to pay the higher fees you are probably being charged, and that they are justified,” he says.

Related Posts

There are 0 Comment(s)

If you wish to comment without signing in, click your cursor in the top box and tick the 'Sign in as a guest' box at the bottom.

Flight cancelled or delayed? Your rights explained

With no sign of the problems in UK aviation easing over the peak summer period, many will worry whether holida...

Rail strikes: Your travel and refund rights

Thousands of railway workers will strike across three days this week, grinding much of the transport system to...

How your monthly bills could rise as the base rate reaches 1.25%

The Bank of England has raised the base rate to 1.25% as predicted – the fifth consecutive rise in just six ...

What will happen if rates change

How your finances will be impacted by a rise in interest rates.

Regular Savings Calculator

Small regular contributions can build up nicely over time.

Online Savings Calculator

Work out how your online savings can build over time.

DIY investors: 10 common mistakes to avoid

For those without the help and experience of an adviser, here are 10 common DIY investor mistakes to avoid.

Mortgage down-valuations: Tips to avoid pulling out of a house sale

Down-valuations are on the rise. So, what does it mean for home buyers, and what can you do?

Five tips for surviving a bear market mauling

The S&P 500 has slipped into bear market territory and for UK investors, the FTSE 250 is also on the edge. Her...

Money Tips of the Week